South Africa’s first female deputy-president helped redefine what leadership could look like in Africa. Her greatest strength may have been the composure with which she exercised it.
There are many ways to make history. Some people do it by breaking down doors. Others simply walk through them, conducting themselves with such authority that the doors remain open for those who follow. Dr. Phumzile Mlambo-Ngcuka, who has died aged 71, belonged to the second category. She was a pioneer, certainly, but not the sort who needed to remind everybody of it. Her achievement was considerable; her manner was understated. In a political world that often mistakes volume for authority, she demonstrated the power of quiet confidence.
When she became South Africa’s deputy-president in 2005, she made history as the first woman to hold the office. It was an appointment of considerable symbolic importance, not merely for South Africa but for a continent in which political leadership remained, and in many places still remains, stubbornly male. Women had participated in Africa’s liberation struggles, organised communities, sustained political movements and carried much of the burden of public life. Yet when the rewards of political independence were distributed, the commanding heights of government were usually reserved for men.
Mlambo-Ngcuka’s arrival in the second-highest office in South Africa’s government challenged that arrangement. She did not arrive as a token representative of women’s advancement. She arrived as a politician with a substantial record of public service, a formidable understanding of government and a long apprenticeship in the country’s democratic transition.
Born in Clermont, KwaZulu-Natal, in 1955, she came of age in a country whose political and social arrangements were designed to deny the majority of its people both dignity and opportunity. Her education reflected an intellectual curiosity that crossed national and disciplinary boundaries. She studied at the National University of Lesotho, obtained a qualification in Gender Policy and Planning from University College London, and subsequently earned a master’s degree from the University of Cape Town and a doctorate in Technology and Education from the University of Warwick, acquiring an academic grounding that complemented her experience in the liberation movement and public life. She was also a teacher by training, an experience that perhaps helps explain her enduring interest in education as an instrument of social transformation. For Mlambo-Ngcuka, the struggle for freedom was never simply about transferring political power; it was about creating the conditions in which ordinary people, particularly women and the young, could realise their potential. Education and liberation would remain recurring themes in her public life: The conviction that human potential was widely distributed, even when opportunity was not.
Following South Africa’s first democratic elections in 1994, she entered Parliament as a member of the African National Congress (ANC). Her rise through the new democratic state was remarkably swift. In 1996, when she was still in her 30s, the great Nelson Mandela appointed her deputy minister of trade and industry, making her one of the youngest members of his cabinet, alongside Geraldine Fraser-Moleketi. It was a significant early vote of confidence from a president who understood the importance of bringing a new generation into the work of building democratic South Africa.
She went on to become minister of minerals and energy, a position she held from 1999 to 2004, before briefly heading the Ministry of Arts, Culture, Science and Technology in 2004. Her ministerial career reflected the breadth of her interests and abilities, moving between the hard calculations of economic policy and the less easily measured business of cultural and intellectual development. Her progression under Mandela and subsequently Thabo Mbeki suggested a politician whose abilities had earned the confidence of two presidents who shaped the country’s democratic transition.
Her tenure as minister of minerals and energy was no insignificant assignment. South Africa’s mineral wealth had long been at the centre of its political economy, and the mining industry was among the most powerful inheritances of the apartheid era. Reforming it required more than fine speeches about transformation. It required confronting entrenched interests and changing the rules governing access to the country’s mineral resources. Mlambo-Ngcuka was associated with the introduction of a new system of mining rights, an important part of the effort to transform ownership and participation in the sector.
Then came the deputy-presidency. When Thabo Mbeki appointed her in 2005, she became South Africa’s first woman to occupy the office. It was a historic appointment, but one that was not received without political controversy. Mlambo-Ngcuka replaced Jacob Zuma after his dismissal by Mbeki, amid the political turmoil surrounding the arms-deal controversy and the corruption allegations against Zuma. Critics were quick to interpret her elevation as an attempt by Mbeki to consolidate his own political base by promoting a trusted ally. Her marriage to Bulelani Ngcuka, then a prominent figure in the country’s prosecution service, also attracted political scrutiny.
There was, therefore, more to her appointment than its historic significance. She entered one of the highest offices in the land at a moment of considerable tension within the governing ANC, with her political loyalties, personal associations and relationship with the president all becoming subjects of public discussion.
Yet Mlambo-Ngcuka’s response was characteristically measured. She was not a politician given to making every disagreement a public spectacle or every political challenge an occasion for personal drama. Her composure was not an absence of conviction. It was a way of exercising it. She appeared more interested in the responsibilities of the office than in the theatre that so often surrounded it.
This quality deserves more attention than it usually receives in assessments of African leadership. Politics on the continent has too often rewarded the performance of strength: The forceful speech, the commanding personality, the ability to dominate a room. Mlambo-Ngcuka offered a different model. She could be firm without being needlessly combative, authoritative without being overbearing, and ambitious without appearing consumed by the pursuit of power.
There is a particular significance to this in the experience of women in public life. Women who enter male-dominated institutions are often subjected to contradictory expectations. They must demonstrate authority but risk being judged abrasive when they do; they must be conciliatory but risk being dismissed as weak. The standards are rarely applied equally to their male counterparts. Mlambo-Ngcuka navigated this difficult terrain with a steadiness that was itself a form of political intelligence.
There was also something distinctly personal about the way she carried herself. Someone who knew her, reflecting on her life, told Inflection: “She was a true African woman who embodied the values she believed in, not simply through what she said but through the way she spoke, dressed and conducted herself. She was reserved, dignified and comfortable in her own skin, a woman whose presence did not depend on conspicuous displays of authority.”
It is an interesting observation, particularly in an age when public figures are often encouraged to cultivate visibility and turn every conviction into a declaration. Mlambo-Ngcuka seemed to understand that there were other ways of making an impression. Her feminism and her commitment to women’s advancement did not require her to abandon the cultural identity and personal values that shaped her. Nor did she appear to regard quietness as something that needed correcting. She could be a woman of considerable ambition and international influence while remaining, in her personal bearing, understated and reserved.
The person who knew her described her as a model of a wife, mother, woman and public figure. That description may sound traditional, but it points to something important about the breadth of her identity. She did not have to choose between being an African woman rooted in her cultural sensibilities and being a formidable participant in the modern political and international order. She inhabited both worlds without apparent contradiction.
Her approach to public life was similarly unshowy. She was not particularly drawn to grandstanding or the politics of slogans. Even within the ANC’s Women’s League, her quieter style did not always attract the recognition that more conspicuous forms of political activism commanded. Yet she continued to do the work, and the reach of that work eventually extended well beyond South Africa’s borders. Her appointment to lead UN Women was perhaps the most compelling illustration of how far a woman who rarely sought the limelight could travel through the force of her ability and commitment.
Her career after government took her onto a larger international stage. In 2013 she became executive director of UN Women, with the rank of United Nations under-secretary-general. She held the position until 2021. It was a fitting destination for a politician whose career had been shaped by the conviction that democracy was incomplete if women remained excluded from its opportunities and institutions.
At the United Nations, she became one of the most recognisable African voices in the global campaign for gender equality. She championed women’s economic empowerment, political participation and the elimination of violence against women and girls. Her leadership coincided with a period in which the world was being forced to confront the persistence of gender inequality, even in societies that considered themselves advanced.
The Covid-19 pandemic made the task still more urgent. Women bore a disproportionate burden of job losses, unpaid care work and domestic violence during the crisis. Under her leadership, UN Women drew attention to these inequalities and pressed governments to ensure that recovery efforts did not leave women further behind.
She also helped bring African perspectives into conversations that were frequently dominated by Western institutions and assumptions. This mattered. Gender equality was not a foreign idea to be imported into Africa, nor was it a concession to be granted by men in positions of authority. It was a question of rights, economic justice and the full participation of half the population in the continent’s development.
Her international career also demonstrated something important about African leadership. Mlambo-Ngcuka was not simply an African politician who had found a place in the international system. She was a figure who could shape its agenda. She understood the diplomatic language of multilateral institutions, but her experience was rooted in the practical realities of a society that had fought to dismantle an exceptionally brutal system of racial exclusion.
Yet it would be too easy to remember her only as a symbol of progress. Her career, like that of any senior politician, unfolded amid the compromises, rivalries and disappointments of government. South Africa’s democratic promise has remained unevenly fulfilled. The country continues to struggle with unemployment, inequality, institutional weakness and the distance between constitutional ideals and ordinary experience. No individual minister or deputy-president could have resolved these problems, and Mlambo-Ngcuka should not be judged as though she could.
But there is a distinction between what a political leader achieves in office and what that leader makes possible for others. By occupying positions in which African women had been largely absent, she enlarged the possibilities of political life. A young woman contemplating a career in government no longer had to imagine leadership exclusively through the example of men. There was now a woman who had served as South Africa’s deputy-president, and who had subsequently led a major United Nations agency.
Representation is sometimes dismissed as symbolism. That is a mistake. Symbols shape expectations, and expectations shape institutions. The first woman to occupy a powerful office changes the argument about who belongs there. The second and third may find the door a little less difficult to open.
Mlambo-Ngcuka’s contribution was not confined to the symbolism of being first. She had the experience, political judgement and international standing to make that first matter. Her career also challenged the notion that women must imitate the most aggressive styles of male political leadership to succeed. She showed that calmness could coexist with ambition, that restraint could be a source of strength and that a leader did not have to dominate every conversation to influence its outcome.
Perhaps this is the quality for which she deserves to be remembered most fondly. Africa has produced many powerful political personalities. It has produced fewer leaders who understood that authority need not always announce itself. Mlambo-Ngcuka’s was a quieter form of power: The power of preparation, persistence, institutional experience and self-possession.
She leaves behind her husband, Bulelani Ngcuka, their four children, and a public legacy that stretches from the struggle against apartheid to the corridors of the United Nations. But her inheritance belongs to a much wider constituency: The African women and girls who will enter public life with a slightly broader sense of what is possible.
There is a description offered by someone who knew her that seems particularly fitting: The African matriarch. It captures something that titles and official biographies cannot quite convey. She was a woman who occupied positions of extraordinary public responsibility without allowing those positions to overwhelm the quieter, more personal dimensions of her identity. She could be a wife, a mother, an African woman deeply conscious of her cultural inheritance, and an international figure of considerable influence. None of these identities had to cancel out the others.
She did not need to raise her voice to make history. She had the confidence to let her work speak, the composure to withstand the political storms around her and the capacity to exercise authority without constantly advertising it. She needed only to occupy the room, do the work and leave it harder for those who came after her to be told that it was not theirs.
The African matriarch has fallen. But the possibilities she helped create will outlive her.