An electoral commission that needs the President to defend its credibility risks surrendering the very independence it was established to protect.
There is something profoundly irregular about President William Ruto stepping forward to defend the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) against criticism over its preparedness and impartiality ahead of the 2027 General Election.
The problem is not that the President has spoken about the IEBC. Every Kenyan, including the President, has a right to express an opinion about public institutions. The problem is the position he has chosen to occupy in this unfolding controversy, the political circumstances in which he has spoken, and the impression his intervention risks creating about the relationship between State House and the country’s electoral referee.
The IEBC does not need a presidential defender. It needs to demonstrate that it is independent of the President.
President Ruto is not a neutral observer of the 2027 presidential contest. He is the incumbent Head of State, a political actor with an obvious interest in the outcome of the election, and one of the individuals whose presidential ambitions are being tracked by Inflection. Our publication’s Those Who Would Lead You project now follows 23 individuals associated with presidential ambitions ahead of the August 10, 2027 General Election. William Samoei Ruto is among them.
That fact should be impossible for the IEBC to overlook.
When the President speaks about the electoral commission, he speaks not merely as Head of State but also as a politician with a direct stake in the electoral process. He is entitled to his political opinions. He is entitled to defend his administration. He is entitled to campaign when the law permits him to do so. But he cannot be treated as the ultimate authority on whether the electoral commission is prepared, credible or deserving of public confidence.
That responsibility belongs to the people of Kenya and IEBC itself.
On November 19, Ruto criticised opposition leaders over their confrontation with the Commission and reportedly told them not to direct their anger at IEBC but to face him in the election. On November 21, he again defended the Commission, accusing critics of looking for scapegoats in public institutions and urging them to allow institutions to work.
These statements deserve serious scrutiny.
The President may believe he is defending a constitutional institution. But the electoral commission must understand that presidential defence can be politically costly. It risks creating the impression that the Commission and the presidency are on the same side of a political argument, precisely when the Commission should be demonstrating that it stands above all political sides.
An electoral commission cannot afford that perception.
Independence is not a presidential favour
The word Independent is not decorative in the name Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission. It is a constitutional obligation.
Article 249(2) of the Constitution of Kenya is unequivocal: Independent commissions are subject only to the Constitution and the law and are not subject to the direction or control of any person or authority.
Not the President. Not the opposition. Not the governing party. Not the government of the day. Not foreign interests!
The Commission’s independence is not something a President grants, protects or validates through public declarations. It is a constitutional guarantee that the Commission itself must defend through its conduct, decisions and public accountability.
Indeed, the IEBC is the referee in a contest in which the President is one of the principal political participants. What would Kenyans think of a football referee whose credibility was being defended by one of the teams competing for the trophy? Would the other teams be unreasonable to demand that the referee speak for himself or herself? An electoral referee must never appear to owe its legitimacy to one of the contestants.
The President should therefore be careful not to place the Commission in a position where his political pronouncements are mistaken for its institutional position. And the IEBC should be even more careful not to allow such an impression to take root.
IEBC must speak for IEBC
The Commission’s silence, or apparent inability to assert its own institutional position with sufficient authority, is becoming increasingly problematic.
When opposition leaders raise questions about electoral preparedness, procurement, voter registration, election technology and transparency, it is not the President’s responsibility to answer those questions on the Commission’s behalf.
It is the IEBC’s responsibility.
If the concerns are unfounded, the Commission should demonstrate why, using evidence, documents, timelines and clear explanations. If there are genuine shortcomings, it should acknowledge them and explain how they are being addressed. What it cannot do is allow political leaders to become its public relations machinery.
The IEBC must also understand that criticism is not necessarily an attack on it. In a democracy, questioning an electoral commission is not an act of hostility against the Constitution. It is an essential part of public accountability.
Indeed, an institution confident in its preparedness should welcome scrutiny. It should not need politicians to dismiss its critics.
President Ruto’s suggestion that those questioning the Commission should apply for jobs there rather misses the point. Kenyans do not need to become IEBC employees to demand transparency in the management of an institution funded by public money and entrusted with their sovereign right to choose their leaders.
The right to scrutinise the electoral commission belongs to every Kenyan.
Four investigations, one troubling picture
Inflection has spent considerable editorial and investigative attention examining the challenges confronting the IEBC.
Our four-part investigation has examined the internal turmoil testing IEBC’s readiness, the increasingly contentious procurement battles surrounding election technology and ballot papers – which led to the cancellation of the ballot papers tender – the constitutional obligations facing the Commission, and the communication failures threatening public confidence.
These are not peripheral questions. Our investigation into internal instability raised concerns about acting appointments, staff movements, disputed promotions and the management environment within the Commission.
Our subsequent investigation into tender disputes examined the legal challenges surrounding procurement of election technology and ballot papers, including questions about competition, local content and transparency.
Our constitutional investigation examined the Commission’s obligations regarding electoral integrity, voter access, transparency, political violence and accountability.
Our final investigation examined the Commission’s communication crisis, including the gaps in its ability to respond convincingly to public concerns and explain its decisions.
Taken together, these investigations present a serious institutional challenge that cannot be wished away by presidential statements about allowing institutions to work.
We have already made our position clear in our editorial, IEBC Must Get Its House in Order: Kenya Cannot Afford Another Electoral Disaster. The Commission must get its house in order. It must resolve internal management challenges, demonstrate procurement integrity, strengthen its institutional communication and establish that its electoral preparations are proceeding according to law and verifiable timelines.
These are responsibilities that belong to IEBC, not State House. And they cannot be discharged by the President assuring Kenyans that the Commission is staffed by competent people.
Competence must be demonstrated. Preparedness must be evidenced. Independence must be visible.
The President must be treated like every other political contender
There is another fundamental issue that the IEBC must confront. The President cannot enjoy a special relationship with the Commission simply because he occupies State House. In electoral matters, the Commission must maintain the same institutional distance from every person seeking political office.
Whether the individual is the incumbent President, a former Deputy President, a party leader, an opposition figure or an independent aspirant, the rules must be the same.
The IEBC must not allow the stature of the presidency to create an impression of privileged access, preferential treatment or political alignment.
This is particularly important because Ruto is not simply commenting on an abstract constitutional question. He is a political figure whose own electoral interests will be determined, in part, by the institution he is publicly defending.
The IEBC should therefore make its position unmistakably clear: It has no preferred presidential aspirant, no favoured political party and no political interest in the outcome of the 2027 election beyond delivering a free, fair, transparent and credible contest.
It should also remind all political actors, including the President, that the Commission’s independence is not negotiable.
The commission must call the President to order
We believe the IEBC should now issue a clear and unequivocal institutional statement.
It should remind the President, respectfully but firmly, that it is an independent constitutional commission and that its credibility must rest on its own record, not on endorsements or assurances from political leaders.
It should make clear that all presidential aspirants, including the incumbent, will be subjected to the same electoral rules and standards.
It should further state that it neither requires nor solicits political defence from any aspirant and that it will independently respond to all legitimate questions about its preparedness and impartiality.
This is not an invitation to pick a fight with the President. It is a demand that the Commission protect its constitutional standing.
The Commission must also demonstrate that it can engage the opposition, civil society, political parties, the media and ordinary citizens without interpreting every difficult question as an attempt to undermine it.
It is entirely possible to respect an institution while demanding answers from it. Indeed, that is precisely what constitutional democracy requires.
Kenya cannot afford an IEBC that looks politically aligned
Our electoral history should have taught us that public confidence is not a luxury. It is a prerequisite for the acceptance of election results and the peaceful transfer or retention of political power.
The 2027 General Election will be too consequential for the country to enter it with unresolved questions about the electoral referee.
The IEBC must appreciate that perceptions matter, particularly when they concern the independence of the institution that will determine the official outcome of a contest involving the country’s highest political office.
A commission can insist that it is independent. But if its conduct, communication or relationships create reasonable grounds for doubt, it must do more than repeat that assertion.
It must demonstrate independence in practice.
The President should defend his political record and submit himself to the same electoral rules as every other aspirant. The opposition should be free to question the Commission without being dismissed as enemies of constitutional institutions. And the IEBC must demonstrate, through transparent and impartial conduct, that it belongs to no political camp.
There is a simple principle at stake here: The President does not own the IEBC, and the IEBC does not owe the President its credibility. The Commission owes its allegiance to the Constitution and the Kenyan people. It must defend that independence itself. Not through the President. Not through the opposition. Not through political endorsements. Through its actions.
And if it cannot confidently and convincingly do so, Kenyans have every right to ask whether the institution entrusted with safeguarding their democratic choice is sufficiently prepared to discharge that historic responsibility.
Kenya does not need an IEBC that is defended by the President. Kenya needs an IEBC that is demonstrably independent of him.
The lesson of June 24, 2024 must not be forgotten
If there is one lesson Kenya must draw from the Gen Z demonstrations of June 24, it is that public institutions cannot afford to lose sight of the people they were established to serve. When institutions fail in their constitutional responsibilities, dismiss legitimate public concerns or retreat into complacency, the consequences can extend far beyond the institutions themselves. Public frustration, once sufficiently accumulated, can reach a point where even the full might of the State struggles to contain its consequences.
The IEBC should take this lesson particularly seriously. It is one of the most consequential constitutional institutions in the country, entrusted with protecting the people’s sovereign right to choose their leaders. It cannot afford to operate in a cocoon of self-assurance, dismiss criticism or mistake presidential reassurance for public confidence. Nor can it assume that Kenyans will simply trust it because it insists that it is independent.
The Commission must step out of its comfort zone, confront the shortcomings within its ranks, answer difficult questions and demonstrate, beyond reasonable doubt, that it is prepared to conduct a credible election in which every Kenyan can have confidence.
Kenya has paid too high a price for institutional failure to tolerate another electoral crisis. The IEBC must wake up to the gravity of its responsibility, put its house in order and safeguard the country’s democratic future. The time to act is now, not when public confidence has irretrievably collapsed and the country is once again staring into the abyss.